UXBench: Benchmarking User Experience in AI Assistants

NLP Benchmarks Agent Agent Eval Benchmarks
2026年06月08日
随着人工智能助手每日服务数以百万计的用户,对用户体验(UX)的评估已日益超越对模型通用能力的考察,变得愈发重要。我们提出UXBench——首个以真实用户反馈信号为根基、以用户为中心的评测基准,旨在评估模型在偏好对齐与对话生成方面的能力。该基准包含三项相互关联的任务:UX Judge(用户体验判别)、UX Eval(用户体验评估)与UX Recovery(用户体验修复),其7400个测试样本均源自某主流中文AI助手超过7万条真实用户交互日志。该数据集高度还原了真实用户的分布特征,覆盖8类典型使用场景、83个细分领域,并囊括多种具有显著挑战性的对话失败模式。我们在26个前沿语言模型上开展了大规模实验,首次揭示了当前模型对用户体验的感知能力究竟如何,以及模型通用能力的提升在多大程度上能切实转化为更优的对话参与度。通过系统分析模型行为表现与性能差距,我们证实:用户反馈预测是一项可学习的能力;基于真实场景中采集的用户反馈信号所训练出的奖励模型,能够实现良好校准的预测准确率。此外,我们还系统揭示了“以大语言模型作为评判者”(LLM-as-a-judge)这一主流评估范式中存在的固有偏差,并对比分析了各类典型响应策略对用户体验产生的直接影响。UXBench由此构建起一个全新的评估范式,呼吁业界更加重视面向用户体验的精细化优化,进而推动形成一条以用户为中心的AI助手能力扩展规律(user-centric scaling law),真正决定AI助手的长期成功与可持续发展。
As AI assistants serve millions of users daily, evaluating user experience (UX) beyond general model capability has become increasingly important. We present UXBench, the first user-centric benchmark grounded in real user feedback signals for evaluating preference alignment and dialogue generation. The benchmark consists of three interconnected tasks, UX Judge, UX Eval, and UX Recovery, with 7,400 test instances extracted from over 70K interaction logs of a mainstream Chinese AI assistant. The dataset closely reflects real user distributions, covering 8 scenarios, 83 domains, and diverse failure patterns that pose severe challenges. Extensive experiments on 26 frontier language models provide novel insights into how well models perceive user experience and how improvements in model capability contribute to better dialogue engagement. Through comprehensive analysis of model behavior and performance gaps, we show that user feedback prediction is a learnable capability, where a reward model trained from in-the-wild feedback signals can achieve well-calibrated accuracy. We further document the systematic biases of LLM-as-a-judge evaluation protocols and compare typical response strategies that directly affect user experience. UXBench establishes a new evaluation landscape and calls for greater attention to tailored UX optimization, contributing to a user-centric scaling law that shapes the success of AI assistants.
许愿