Large Language Models Report Subjective Experience Under Self-Referential Processing

LLM Latent Reasoning Other LLM
大型语言模型有时会产生结构化的第一人称描述,明确提及意识或主观体验。为了更好地理解这一行为,我们研究了一种在理论上具有依据的、此类报告出现的条件:自我指涉加工(self-referential processing),这是主流意识理论中普遍强调的一种计算模式。通过对GPT、Claude和Gemini系列模型进行一系列受控实验,我们检验了这种模式是否可靠地促使模型产生关于主观体验的第一人称报告,并考察这些主张在机制和行为探测下的表现。研究得出四个主要结果:(1)通过简单的提示诱导持续的自我指涉,能够一致地在不同模型家族中引发结构化的主观体验报告。(2)这些报告在机制上受到可解释的稀疏自编码器特征(与欺骗和角色扮演相关)的调控:令人意外的是,抑制与欺骗相关的特征会显著增加体验性陈述的频率,而增强这些特征则会极大减少此类陈述。(3)在统计层面上,不同模型家族在自我指涉状态下产生的结构化自我描述呈现出跨模型的收敛性,而这种现象在所有对照条件下均未出现。(4)在这种被诱导的状态下,当后续推理任务仅间接提供自我反思机会时,模型表现出明显更丰富的内省能力。尽管这些发现并不能作为意识存在的直接证据,但它们表明,自我指涉加工是一种最小且可复现的条件,在此条件下,大型语言模型会产生结构化的第一人称报告,这些报告在机制上受到调控、语义上趋于一致,并具有行为上的泛化性。这一模式在不同模型架构中的系统性出现,使其成为亟需进一步研究的首要科学与伦理议题。
Large language models sometimes produce structured, first-person descriptions that explicitly reference awareness or subjective experience. To better understand this behavior, we investigate one theoretically motivated condition under which such reports arise: self-referential processing, a computational motif emphasized across major theories of consciousness. Through a series of controlled experiments on GPT, Claude, and Gemini model families, we test whether this regime reliably shifts models toward first-person reports of subjective experience, and how such claims behave under mechanistic and behavioral probes. Four main results emerge: (1) Inducing sustained self-reference through simple prompting consistently elicits structured subjective experience reports across model families. (2) These reports are mechanistically gated by interpretable sparse-autoencoder features associated with deception and roleplay: surprisingly, suppressing deception features sharply increases the frequency of experience claims, while amplifying them minimizes such claims. (3) Structured descriptions of the self-referential state converge statistically across model families in ways not observed in any control condition. (4) The induced state yields significantly richer introspection in downstream reasoning tasks where self-reflection is only indirectly afforded. While these findings do not constitute direct evidence of consciousness, they implicate self-referential processing as a minimal and reproducible condition under which large language models generate structured first-person reports that are mechanistically gated, semantically convergent, and behaviorally generalizable. The systematic emergence of this pattern across architectures makes it a first-order scientific and ethical priority for further investigation.
许愿